MHA | Not taking “No” for an answer: rejected holiday requests…

Not taking “No” for an answer: rejected holiday requests leading to unauthorised absence

Stephanie Pote · October 6th 2016 · read

People in room talking urgently

Keeping with the theme of holidays which has been running through our recent blog posts (Does your Holiday Year run from April to March? You might have a problem, and Should you change the Holiday Year for your business?) we now explore the common problems employers face in connections to employees taking holiday:

“My holiday request was declined but I will still go on holiday because it’s all already arranged”

Requests for annual leave by employees should be given with notice of at least twice the length of leave requested (or longer if so agreed in the employment contract or the absence policy). Employers have the right to refuse annual leave requests and must do so with a notice at least equal to the length of leave requested. There is no legal requirement to give reason for refusal but it is good practice to do so, especially to safeguard the mutual trust and confidence that exists between the employer and employee. The request should only be refused on basis on genuine business needs and in good faith.

A good absence policy will stipulate that employees shouldn’t commit to firm holiday arrangements before annual leave has been authorised. It will normally say that the employees must not make any positive holiday arrangements before the leave request has been approved. By the same token, the employer should reply to any requests promptly to allow employees sufficient time to make the holiday arrangements.

If the employee still takes holiday despite the refusal, this can be treated as unauthorised leave and the disciplinary process will apply when dealing with it. Note that an investigation will still need to be undertaken and a fair disciplinary hearing held before any sanction can be issued.

“They refused my holiday so I will pull a sickie”

If the employee calls in sick on the same days they previously requested annual leave for (and the request was refused), the employer may ask for a doctor’s note as evidence of genuine sickness. You must ensure that you reserve the right to do this in the employment contract or in the sickness absence or leave policies. As doctors generally only issue these after eight days of sickness, you might need to pay for the note.

When the employee returns to work you should hold a return to work meeting and ask them how they are feeling. You should not accuse the employee of lying unless you have clear evidence but you can explain what impact their absence had on their colleagues and whether they see why the company might take a view that the sickness is not genuine given it occurred at the same time as the refused holiday request.

“My return flight was changed to arrive on the day after I am meant to be back at work; maybe they won’t notice”

Returning late from a holiday is likely to constitute unauthorised absence which can result in disciplinary action and it is really important that employees are aware of this. It is important to examine whether employees are given guidance on what to do if their travel plans are disrupted or something else prevents them from returning from holiday on time.  You should never make assumptions about the reason for their delay and, in absence of their contact; you should try contacting them either by phone or email. Make note of every attempt and take brief notes of the conversation if you manage to speak to the employee. You might also want to speak to their emergency contacts if you are still unable to ascertain what is going on. If you are unsuccessful you should write to the employee explaining this is unauthorised absence and you will be initiating disciplinary process.

If you need any help tacking these or similar situations, don’t hesitate to contact our HR Solutions team

Share this article
Related tags